Complications: A Surgeon’s Note on an Imperfect Science

Examining the life of a surgeon through the shoes of surgical resident Dr. Gawande

Complications: A Surgeon’s Note on an Imperfect Science is a novel about Dr. Atul Gawande’s period as a surgical resident at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston, Massachusetts, specifically training to be a general surgeon. This novel includes a great deal of Dr. Gawande’s brooding on many different aspects of medicine as it related to him and his residency experiences. He explores, with great depth and insight, many ethical and practical problems presented in medicine and how he has learned to deal with them. The book is a must-read for any person who aspires to be a doctor one day.


Dr. Atul Gawande

“Observe one, do one, teach one” is a common saying heard in every residency program around the US. Early on in his surgical residency, Dr. Gawande had to put in a central line within the first month of starting his residency only after seeing the chief resident do two of them on her own. A central line is a long tube that goes into the patient’s vena cava in their heart for various different reasons, one being to give medications or fluids quickly. First, the doctor inserts the needle with a syringe into the subclavian vein under the patient’s clavicle and sees maroon blood filling the syringe that the surgeon subsequently removes. The surgeon then threads the guide wire through the needle and maneuvers it to the vena cava, removing the needle thereafter. After putting and taking out the dilator to expand the opening of the vein, the surgeon will finally thread the catheter in and maneuver it into the vena cava, so they can finally take out the needle. Dr. Gawande knew the textbook process, but he also knew that there were many inherent associated risks such as heavy internal bleeding, cardiac arrest, and lung collapse. Indeed, Dr. Gawande actually failed to put in a central line the first three times that he tried. On the fourth time, he was successful, and he could hardly explain what he did differently. In the end, surgery is all about practice. Gawande notes that “attending surgeons say that what’s most important to them is finding people who are conscientious, industrious, and boneheaded enough to stick at practicing this one difficult thing day and night for years on end” (Gawande 19). Often, it takes forever to do something exactly right in surgery, but the only way to do it is to keep practicing. Eventually, Dr. Gawande came into a position where he was the one supervising a junior resident as she put in a central line in a patient. She, like Dr. Gawande before, had immense trouble setting up the central line, and every bone in Dr. Gawande wanted to take the central line and do it himself. However, she had to practice it if she ever wanted to learn how to do it. Letting a resident practice these procedures presents us with a moral dilemma that Dr. Gawande goes into great detail about: if the job is to give the patient the best possible care, then residents should never do surgeries because the attending surgeon will always give better care. However, the only way to train surgeons for the future is to allow them to do surgeries under the supervision of the attending. Where this understanding gets uncertain is when people from a surgeon’s family come in for surgery. In this case, the attending surgeon will always do that surgery on his own, allowing the resident only to observe. Often, the people that residents are allowed to practice and do surgeries on without supervision are only the drunk, uninsured, and poor.


Inserted Central Line

Surgery is always constantly evolving. New techniques and procedures come out, and surgeons must learn how to use them to give their patients the best treatment possible. Nevertheless, the first few patients who receive these new techniques and procedures may not be getting this best treatment possible since the practicing surgeons themselves are learning themselves. A study done by Harvard Business School researchers aimed to study the learning curve of heart surgeons as they learned how to do a minimally invasive cardiac surgery. The surgeons that were the most successful chose “team members with whom he had worked well before and [kept] them together through the first fifteen cases before allowing any new members. He had the team go through a dry run before the first case, then deliberately scheduled six operations in the first week, so little would be forgotten in between. He convened the team before each case to discuss it in detail and afterward to debrief” (29). It was not that this surgeon was the most experienced, but he was the most humble in the sense that he became a member of the surgical team rather than the de facto leader. This allowed these surgeons to be the best at doing these minimally invasive cardiac surgeries. Still, these surgeons, like all others, do make mistakes, sometimes deadly. To deal with this in a positive way, most hospitals have a Morbidity and Mortality (M&M) Conference each week to discuss these mistakes and learn from them without the threat of being sued for what they share. In Dr. Gawande’s case, all members of the hospital assembled there as each chief resident from various specialties came up to discuss the cases in regards to their specialty. Often, this can become embarrassing for certain doctors, but that is not the purpose. This conference is meant to be a learning experience to improve patient care at the hospital. “No matter what measures are taken, doctors will sometimes falter, and it isn’t reasonable to ask that we achieve perfection. What is reasonable is to ask that we never cease to aim for it,” and that is the lesson M&M seeks to remind doctors of (74).


Mortality and Morbidity Conference at the University of Hawai’i

Despite the mistakes, surgery has the potential to change lives for the better. Dr. Gawande has multiple examples of them in his book, but I chose two of the most interesting ones in my opinion. Vincent Caselli was a morbidly obese man at 428 pounds. Dr. Gawande with the assisting surgeon Dr. Randall performed a Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass (RYGB) surgery on him, which works by stapling the stomach so that it becomes smaller and then connecting it to the middle part of the small intestine to bypass the first part. Thus, the patient will reach satiety even by eating extremely little, which helps them lose weight in the long term. This surgery was important since Caselli’s obesity was affecting his quality of life: he had to sleep in a recliner chair on the first floor unable to reach his bedroom on the second floor, had to shower after going to the bathroom because keeping adequate hygiene otherwise was difficult, and had to leave his construction company that he started, watching it fail without him. It was not that Caselli could not lose weight; he had trouble keeping it off like almost everyone. There was a panel that looked at various studies that showed more than nine out of ten people regained about half of the weight they lost after one year and all of it after five years. However, this surgery changed Caselli’s life. It took a while and also involved lifestyle changes, but he was able to get to 250 pounds. His quality of life improved dramatically: he finally was able to leave the house and go do things he enjoyed like seeing a Boston Bruins game and work full time. He told Dr. Gawande that surgery gave him control of his life back. Surgery can change people’s lives for the better, and the case regarding Eleanor Bratton, a young woman with a swollen maroon leg that was warm to the touch, is another example of this. The story started when an ER doctor told Dr. Gawande that she probably had severe cellulitis, but Dr. Gawande was not convinced. One possibility, necrotizing fasciitis, popped into his mind because of a patient that he had a few weeks before. This patient presented with similar symptoms and was diagnosed with cellulitis. However, his condition worsened, and he was taken from a small community hospital to Brigham and Women’s where he was properly diagnosed with having necrotizing fasciitis. Despite surgery to remove the infected muscle and amputation of the arm, the patient died after all his vital organs failed on him. Necrotizing fasciitis is an aggressive infection, known as the flesh-eating disease. The bacteria is highly aggressive since the tissue infection spreads rapidly and cannot be treated by antibiotics alone. Early diagnosis and treatment improve prognosis, but many with the infection have some of their appendages amputated and/or die. The condition is extremely rare compared to the common cellulitis, and the general surgeon on call said that the chance it was necrotizing fasciitis was far less than 5%. In spite of that, Dr. Gawande could not ignore the chance that it was necrotizing fasciitis. The problem was that there was no way of differentiating between cellulitis and necrotizing fasciitis except for doing a biopsy. This came as a shock to Bratton and her father, both of whom reluctantly gave permission to do the biopsy. Once done, a dermatopathologist had to be called to examine the tissue, determining that Bratton indeed had necrotizing fasciitis. The general surgeon on call, Dr. Studdert, was considering doing a below-knee amputation or an above-knee amputation; however, he decided to do a debridement, which meant he took out the most infected tissue in the leg and flushed the leg with saline. Nevertheless, the situation was not ideal since there was a lot of the infection still left because an amputation was not done. Thus, Dr. Studdert had Bratton undergo hyperbaric oxygen therapy. This worked by putting a patient in a pressure chamber with a great deal of oxygen to speed up the healing since the immune system actually uses oxygen to fight infections. The therapy ended up working and after four more surgeries to take out the infected tissue, Bratton ended up being discharged from the hospital. It took some time and lot of physical therapy for Bratton to be able to use her leg for weight-bearing exercises, but it did not matter much to her because she still had her leg, and she was still alive. She escaped probable death because Dr. Gawande shrewdly considered all the possibilities to give the life-saving early diagnosis of necrotizing fasciitis.


Necrotizing Fasciitis on a Patient’s Arm

Dr. Gawande writes masterfully with such thought-provoking material and great insight on it. It always kept me engaged as I read about his examining of cases that are some of the most interesting in medicine. The women who could not stop compulsively blushing, the man who had disabling untreatable back pain despite not having any associated trauma, and the women who had hyperemesis gravidarum (severe nausea) that persisted throughout her entire pregnancy despite all kinds of intervention. I cannot do this book and its author the justice that they both deserve, and only be reading it entirely can one appreciate its authenticity and reality.



Ahmed, Burhan. “Central Line Placement: A Step-by-Step Procedure Guide.” Medicalopedia, 19 Nov. 2010, Accessed 24 Aug. 2017.

Central Venous Catheter. 28 Dec. 2014. NREMT Academy, Accessed 24 Aug. 2017.

Gawande, Atul. Complications: A Surgeon’s Notes on an Imperfect Science. New York, H. Holt, 2002.

—. Complications: A Surgeon’s Notes on an Imperfect Science. Amazon, Accessed 24 Aug. 2017.

Llewellyn, Tim. Atul A. Gawande, MD, MPH. Brigham and Women’s Health, Accessed 24 Aug. 2017.

Necrotizing Fasciitis: The Flesh-Eating Disease You Want Nothing to Do With! 9 Feb. 2017. Science Vibe, Accessed 24 Aug. 2017.

“Roux-En-Y Gastric Bypass.” Web MD, Accessed 24 Aug. 2017.

Scholarly Activities Sessions. Hawaii Residency Programs Inc., Accessed 24 Aug. 2017.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: